Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mixedmath 408 days ago
This will not be taught in textbooks. Wildberger works in a math world where "infinity" or even "really really big numbers" don't exist. There is nothing mathematically wrong about that world, but others (like me) do not find this problem context to be a useful framework to work in.
2 comments

Interesting. So sort of a polar opposite to hyperreal numbers[1]. Instead of postulating de existence of numbers to the infinite and beyond, postulating there is no infinite.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreal_number

> There is nothing mathematically wrong about that world

Thank you for acknowledging this. Every time Norm's work comes up on HN there is a subcurrent of comments about how his philosophy of math is wrong or dumb whose are arguments can be summed up as "Lol no infinity wtf".

Do I personally agree with his philosophy? No. But I still watched all his videos because they are entertaining, thoughtful, and his is rigorous in his definitions and examples.

His channel is sometimes the best way of learning certain topics in classical geometry.
Agreed, his videos on Tropical Algebra are also very good!