[bredren]

Had been planning a custom mcp for our orgs’ jira.

I’m a bit skeptical that it’s gonna work out of the box because of the amount of custom fields that seem to be involved to make successful API requests in our case.

But I would welcome, not having to solve this problem. Jira’s interface is among the worst of all the ticket tracking applications I have encountered.

But, I have found using a LM conversation paired within enough context about what is involved for successful POSTs against the API allow me to create update and relate issues via curl.

It’s begging for a chat based LLM solution like this. I’d just prefer the underlying model not be locked to a vendor.

Atlassian should be solving this for its customers.

[viraptor]

You can also do the same thing locally: https://github.com/sooperset/mcp-atlassian Either with the cloude app, or some other system with any tool-using LLM you want.

[bredren]

I'm familiar with that MCP and was planning to build on top of it.

I hadn't realized but the new integration seems to actually just be an official, closed-source MCP produced *by* Atlassian.

sooperset's MCP is MIT licensed, so I wonder how much of the Atlassian edition is just a lift of that.

There's a comment [1] on the actual integration page asking about custom fields, which I think is possibly a big issue.

At first I thought the open-source version would get crushed by an actual Atlassian release, but not if Atlassian doesn't offer all the support for it to work really well no matter what customizations are fitted into each instance.

My hypothesis is that it takes custom code to make this work, and using the off-the-shelf for Jira won't work. Hoping to be proven wrong though, as it would be less work for me on that front.

[1] https://community.atlassian.com/forums/Atlassian-Platform-ar...