Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by samiv 418 days ago
Let's fix that right there.

Capitalism is a concept, a tool to organize production in a society. It doesn't do anything by itself.

And the capitalist didn't do any of those things.

It was the social democracy that demanded and made capitalists around the world to share the benefits of the system to the rest of the society.

For example in the Victorian era Britain the working class people were dirt poor working 16h a way 7 days a week. The capitalists didn't give anything willingly the working people had to demand these things via unions, labor movements and social democracy.

2 comments

The fundamental precondition for all these changes is that capitalism massively increased the overall wealth of Britain. The market did the rest: higher wages, lower prices, new inventions improving life for everyone, increased living standards.

Workers negotiating and fighting for better condition, and joining forces with other workers have nothing to do with social democracy, it's a normal market mechanism to regulate the supply and demand of workers.

Where social democracy enters is with the political activism and the relative legislation, limiting working hours and banning child labor.

Trying to understand what you're saying, especially with 'let's fix that right there'.

Is it basically the idea that the good we've gotten out of it (like driving down extreme poverty) has required 'social democracy' as another concept or force, to bend capitalism towards something better? And that a more useful perspective is zooming out from just capitalism by itself to include that?

I do feel like I still have a pretty limited understanding of how all of this fits together, so I appreciate you trying to teach me something here.