[ziddoap]

>That comment has exactly what you're asking for

No, it doesn't.

I was hoping to read something that addressed this specific paper. All of those links are papers published before Lior Shamir's paper was published.

The comment I originally replied to said "people pointed out he cherry-picked results". I thought "people" might be "scientists" and they might have pointed it out in a subsequent paper or something.

Thanks though.

[Retric]

The chronology or papers isn’t important here.

The cherry picking is clear from the difference in results not their timing.