I agree with Joel about a lot of things but I don't think history lines up with his famous comments about the Netscape rewrite. Netscape was well on the decline before they began the rewrite and its problems were more lack of commercial focus (eg. their failed attempts at "groupware") rather than the technical decision to rewrite Navigator. And without that rewrite it is unlikely that Firefox would have ever existed and without Firefox, Netscape (now Mozilla) would have slid into the abyss of irrelevance a long time ago.
So while there are certainly good arguments to be made that rewrites can bite you in the ass and should often (though not always, IMO) be avoided, I wish people would stop referencing Joel's circa-2000 post unless they are willing to rewrite it in hindsight and still attempt to make his argument.
So while there are certainly good arguments to be made that rewrites can bite you in the ass and should often (though not always, IMO) be avoided, I wish people would stop referencing Joel's circa-2000 post unless they are willing to rewrite it in hindsight and still attempt to make his argument.