Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by koakuma-chan 426 days ago
> I genuinely cannot see how Rust would be able to scale to something usable for all system applications the way it is now. Is every graphical application supposed to duplicate and statically link the entire set of GNOME/GTK or KDE/Qt libraries it needs? The system would become ginormous.

You don't have to statically link C libraries.
1 comments
whytevuhuni 426 days ago
I am referring to Rust scaling up to where C is now (i.e. try to remove C from the picture).

As in, if there will ever be a Rust equivalent of KDE/GNOME (e.g. maybe COSMIC), it will have similar libraries. They will have to be in Rust, and will have to be statically linked. And they will eventually grow up to be the size of KDE/GNOME (as opposed to the tiny thing COSMIC is now).

link
ryao 426 days ago
If it is any consolation, early C did not have dynamic linking either. It was added afterward. From what I understand, UNIX systems had statically linked binaries in /bin until ELF was introduced and gradually switched to dynamically linked binaries afterward.
link