[danpalmer]

The problem with HCL is that it's a Level 4 language masquerading as a Level 3 language, rather than a Level 4 language masquerading as a Level 5 (like Starlark, Dhall, even JSONNET). Because of that its syntax is very limited and it needs awkwardly nuanced semantics, and becomes difficult to use well as a result.

HCL is best used when the problem you're solving is nearly one you could use a level 3 language for, whereas in my experience, Starlark is only really worth it when what you need is nearly Python.