Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by potatolicious 5055 days ago
This is a tiresome argument that's been repeated over and over, and is nothing more than an attempt to change the subject.

Inevitably it starts when someone complains about the "parasites", "moochers", or whatever the description of the day is. It's always "waaah! someone undeserving is getting my stuff!"

When the notion that nobody exists as an island is pointed out, and it becomes clear that those complaining about the "moochers" are in fact enormous beneficiaries of the system, the argument becomes "but the system isn't perfect!", as if that somehow justifies the "every man for himself" mentality that started the argument.

Objectivist arguments like this always start with the notion that greater good will arise from an objectivist society. When that stupid argument is thrashed good, the argument turns into one of personal freedoms. It's amazing how many about-faces people will make in order to hang onto the notion that everyone else is a useless good-for-nothing except themselves.