[csdvrx]

> Route53 handles this already, health checks, geo routing for pennies. If pointing to AWS services can use alias records.

That would use AWS and insulate you from the details.

The fun part is learning how to do that, which gives you a better idea of how it works and full control of the solution.

You can then think about anycast or getting your own IP blocks

[nodesocket]

I hear you, but I also could write my application in assembly and take 10x as long. If your doing this as a hobby and for fun, sure... But if your trying to launch/scale a company, decisions like this are engineering mode not founder mode.

[csdvrx]

That's fair!

Before using an existing solution, I like to understand how it works to make sure I will not get bad surprises: being able to reverse and debug using assembly code can be a helpful skill, and likewise for understanding DNS.

Yesterday I vibe code a DNS server from scratch in half a day, because I wanted to test something very specific bridging DNS and mDNS. Doing the same thing for health checks and geo routing may take what, another half day?

The experience and understanding gained can help decide if it's worth using a service like route53 or not, or even better: just doing without the feature, because if you have 1 VPS, "YAGNI" is the likely answer!

If the poster is seriously thinking about scaling to 2 VPS or more, the experience gained will expose the various ways it can fail, to maybe reconsider the decision (maybe instead get beefier hardware?)

In my case, I saw the DNS-mDNS isn't much a problem, so I don't have to reconsider adding the feature I want.