Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by delfinom 444 days ago
So with #2, steal everyone's money, even people contributing into 401k while making dogshit pay, and pay off the country's debt bill ran up by someone else?

I can tell you this scenario results in french revolutions

1 comments

Everybody loves to quote french revolution or 2nd amendment but all these revolutions are all centrally lead (by somebody/group performing a power grab).

Whose leading the revolution against 401k theft? Is Vanguard going to invite people with 401ks to a rally in DC?

The French revolution wasn't lead centrally, it was a higher classes which boiled over to grassroots explosion of public discontent that ran away from everyone, had a life of its own, and devoured its children.

Economically, little changed for the regular people. The church was ruined, and so were many high class families. Socially, a lot did (there was an expectation of humans having rights, the church was forever relegated to a secondary role and out of governance, etc).

Most social revolutions (changing the social order, so the US war of independence doesn't count) have a grassroots component that is often highjacked by educated professionals (lawyers are a bit overrepresented) for their own social and economic agenda (which, to be clear, is a net positive compared to the previous order)

when you put it like that, it might actually works. Specially now that the people stealing the 401k will be ones shadowbanning all the angry tweets.

also: see the preemptive strike on revolutions https://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/censored.pdf?mod...