[teeray]

> Git trailers are neat, but ultimately suffer from a UI issue: most people are using interfaces to git that don't use the plumbing, and they put all the important info in the first line (and sometimes have a frustrating cutoff of 50 characters)

It’s not git’s fault if you choose not to use git(1). Trailers work great with it. You can use other tools that claim some level of compliance with git, but you do so with the understanding that YMMV.

[noirscape]

I'm just going by the practical reality here; I personally do like using the git commandline, but the reality is that most people are using Git from forges like GitHub and terrible UI programs like, well, GitHub Desktop, which do both of these things.

Ultimately git is a tool for version control and software collaboration, so what you end up doing should encompass the tools that people use. It's easier to find a compromise than to hardline on a position that requires a lot more upfront work (it's much harder to switch people off of software that they are familiar with than you might expect.)