Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by foofoo55 457 days ago
Why are the Arxiv and Nature versions so different, even the text?
3 comments

As another comment mentioned, papers get revised during review, usually in response to reviewer comments. Also, some journals (not sure about Nature) do not allow authors to "backport" revisions made in response to reviewer comments to preprints; I guess they view the review process as part of their "value add".
Its quite common to revise papers. For example, they might have uploaded to arxiv in order to submit to a conference. Later, they revised and submitted to Nature.
Arxiv is mostly meant for preprints for peer review.

In a Nature paper in particular, the final layout is typically done by the journal's professional production team, not the authors.

Not all publishers grant permission for authors to upload the peer-reviewed and layouted postprints elsewhere.