Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gonzoflip 461 days ago
That's the point, I have a full time("good") job currently, and can barely afford food and rent for my family, I am literally selling plasma 2x a week for gas money, while paying a significant amount of taxes, so why would I work?
1 comments
bryanlarsen 461 days ago
Now imagine getting by with a lot less. That's what UBI-only would be like.

I assume your main problem is that you're in a high cost of life area. A national UBI would almost certainly be set at a level appropriate for a median area. If you want to not work and maintain your standard of living you'd likely have to move to a low COL area.

link
gonzoflip 461 days ago
>national UBI

with what money? we already do a lot of that with de facto negative tax rates for the lowest earners.

You bring up a great option though, I have been working to move to a lower COL(see rural) area already. Part of this plan is a draw down on my participation in the labor market, basically a necessity unless I want to commute multiple hours each way. We have gotten by on much less than I do currently, my QOL was very similar, but I was doing more work for myself and my family, rather than my employer or society.

link
bryanlarsen 461 days ago
> with what money?

Which is why I picked your comment to reply to. People have this inclination that UBI is going to provide a reasonable amount of money. But if you do the math you'll find that about $1500 a month is about the limit that's feasible. You want to increase the tax rate by an amount that has the average adult paying the same amount in extra taxes as they receive via the UBI. $1500 a month gets to European level taxation rates which I figure is about the limit of acceptable.

A couple can live on $3000 a month in some areas of the country, and perhaps a single person can live on $1500 a month in West Virginia.

link
gonzoflip 461 days ago
But even at current levels of taxation I am looking for the exit because it is unsustainable. I am already deciding that the tax burden and COL is too high to justify my participation, and I am working on severely cutting my income and moving away from the city in order to be more self sustaining, and sharing less of my labor with everyone else.

*So my original question still stands, what incentive do I have to participate?

link