Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tasuki 460 days ago
Note this was written by a "software engineer". A designer would have used white space for separation, not a line.
4 comments

The designers behind practically every newspaper (including the New York Times) would disagree with you:

https://store.nytimes.com/cdn/shop/products/new-york-times-f...

If you’re against established, commonly accepted best practices for design, then I can’t argue with you — everyone is entitled to their own opinions, as unpopular as they may be.

I don't think there's only one way to present information.
What are you even getting at here?

Obviously that's how a "designer" or "software engineer" would display items that require whitespace between them.

This proposal is for when you do want something other whitespace.

I'm getting at the fact that designers use white space to visually separate things. People who know nothing about design put lines between things to separate them.
That sounds rather pretentious. There are good places to use whitespace and there are good places to use separators. There's a reason Excel uses lines to separate cells rather than whitespace and it's not because Microsoft never thought to hire a designer.

Going hard on whitespace is just a visual trend that'll undoubtedly change in the future again. It wasn't that long ago that designers went all in on glossy 3D effects with hard separators for basic UI design. You cannot derive someone's qualifications from a subjective aesthetical choice like that.

nonsense, sometimes you want a line