[OtherShrezzing]

I wonder if that opens a threat vector from a security point of view? If an attacker knows that the golden firmware has some critical vulnerability which they can exploit easily, they can activate it at will by bricking the device and waiting for it to restart.

[stego-tech]

They could, and that's been a way for attackers to "jailbreak" devices and load custom firmware in the past. Though for the sake of reducing eWaste and enabling device repurposing and reuse, I do think this is the best path for firmware-updatable devices.

[bmicraft]

Attackers aren't usually in a position to reset firmware, and if they are they might as well do a whole host of other things like replace the device with a compromised one. I don't think there is much of a point to trying to protect from that.

[csomar]

The golden firmware should reset to the old/first firmware of the device and nothing else. Keep it as simple as possible and restore the customer device back to an operational state.

[JoshTriplett]

The problem comes in if that old firmware has security holes, particularly if the device is network-connected.

[bmandale]

The reset would be done physically. If there was some danger of the device being exploited after being reset, advice could be included for those performing the reset to prevent this. For example, to not connect it to a network and to manually perform an update to the latest version with some physical media.