Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xyst 464 days ago
Have seen demos where garbage sorting has been automated. No AI necessary.

Just had cameras, visual detection, some compressed air nozzles, and millisecond (nanosecond?) reaction time to separate the non-recyclable materials.

3 comments

It's funny that we are at a point where "visual detection" is not considered AI anymore.
Some (most?) of these aren't really AI-based at all. For example. traditional optical sorters typically rely on the reflectivity of materials at one or a few laser wavelengths directed onto the material.

The mapping between sensor signals and material types is usually hardcoded from laboratory test results.

Using AI for image recognition is to visual detection as Orange Juice is to beverages.
Sure. What they will call AI [an unspecified number of years in the future] will be compared similarly the the SOTA AI models.

For long time the term "artificial intelligence" has just gone out of favour, but I do remember the days where a good AI research lab had a bunch of symbolics lisp machines

I mean that we have visual recognition systems that do not use any kind of machine learning whatsoever and those are the majority of systems in use at industrial scale.

Laser interferometry and DCT image distance, primarily.

About 199x, Dortmund, Germany...

Lead to nothing. At least not at the time. AFAIK the initial garbage stream is still manually inspected and separated at most sites.

And the people doing that have a much higher risk of getting sick, because of all sorts of bacteria, mold, spores, chemicals, VOC, whatever.

Not to mention the stink.

Haha I just came up with that off the hip (never heard of, seen, or even contemplated sorting garbage before) because the idea that this needs articulation and graspers is the height of "we're VC funded and don't care about anything except runway". Laughable.