Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Jemaclus 467 days ago
OP here. Yeah, the basic answer is "it's for you," but there's certainly value for me.

Consider it this way: if I schedule a 1:1, and you cancel it every week, then that tells me that you don't find time with me to be valuable. How do I fix that? Is that a signal about you hating meetings, or is it a signal that I'm a bad manager?

If I schedule 1:1s, and you join them, and then you give me one word answers to everything I ask, then you clearly don't want to be there. That gives me signals about our relationship: if we had a good relationship, we'd have more comfortablec conversations.

If I schedule 1:1s, and you join them, and you are apathetic or antagonistic, then that also tells me that there's a problem.

The 1:1 is an incredibly valuable period of time for us to have candid conversations, exchange feedback, and develop our relationship. That kind of thing requires two people to tango. I can't force you to do those things. But if you don't want to do those things, and you don't want to ensure that we work well together and can exchange feedback freely, then maybe we don't work well together, and we should re-evaluate our working relationship.

So is it for me? Sort of. The goal is for you to be involved with me in a private but accessible way. You and I having a relationship where we can build on fundamentals and create a safe, welcoming, innovative environment is the single most valuable thing a manager can do and that a report can accelerate and encourage.

But if you don't want to participate in that, then that doesn't bode well for your career at my company.

If you want to take that as "it's for you, not me," then that's fair, but I don't think you and I would work well together.