Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by biorach 462 days ago
> I know many Irish people who are straight up racist towards the English

I'm Irish. I've spent a lot of time in the countryside and the cities. This is not true. It's very rare to find an Irish person who is racist towards the British

> secondary school "Up the Ra" was a common slogan shouted by my classmates.

These days its justa catchy rebel chant. It does not necessarily mean the people chanting it support the IRA

> There's still pubs in Dublin and other places around the country where you wouldn't want to go with an English accent.

No there's not.

I can think of maybe 2 pubs in Dublin you might get an unfrindly welcome. On a bad day.

> But for us Irish, holding onto this old identity of "the oppressed" is a part of our collective psyche

You're really really over stating how prevalent this is

> a quarter of the geographical landmass of Ireland still belongs to the old oppressors. But that's another thing we need to let go off.

We did. Remember the referendum? The one where we collectively voted to remove the territorial claim from our constitution?

Your whole comment is vastly exaggerated.

There's Americans reading. Don't be giving them the wrong ideas, they've enough to be dealing with.

2 comments

> It's very rare to find an Irish person who is racist towards the British

Oh come off it. No it's not. Unless you're in deep denial about what constitutes racism.

> Your whole comment is vastly exaggerated.

Maybe we have different lived experiences? We can both be Irish and have very different lives and experiences, small country though it is.

For me, nothing I said is exaggerated. Irish people do hate to state things directly though, and I'm used to be told to be quiet whenever I speak out about our issues.

> There's Americans reading. Don't be giving them the wrong ideas, they've enough to be dealing with.

Ok can't argue with that one.

Another Irish person here… Going to have to agree with biorach on this one, but not by a lot.

>> It's very rare to find an Irish person who is racist towards the British >Oh come off it. No it's not. Unless you're in deep denial about what constitutes racism.

The Irish that are racist against the British are, in my experience, the American who have things to say about other groups, ethnicities, religions.

Not uncommon, not prolific, but not the crowd you’d go hang out with either.

"There's Americans reading. Don't be giving them the wrong ideas, they've enough to be dealing with."

Thanks for making me laugh for a bit before I went back to staring at my screen in disbelief.