Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by seanalltogether 5062 days ago
I wonder if that is a good solution for separating novices and pros though? For me, hidden files and folders only help to reinforce the confusion people have about computers. It's one thing to provide a folder to a user with a lock or shield on it, it's another to completely hide it from them.
3 comments
brianpan 5062 days ago
Hiding is absolutely good design at every level. Not seeing UI controls, preferences, or anything that is not relevant to the task at hand can make that task simpler, easier to understand, and more productive. If you need to see dotfiles, well, you might need to know about man pages or at least that commandline programs take flags. It's not like they're invisible.

There are plenty of examples: video games slowly reveal more skills as you learn and encounter progressively harder enemies. A good app should be usable at first launch (or only require minimal setup). Configuration and advanced features can come later.

Another great filesystem level example are OS X app bundles- an entire directory hierarchy appears as a single file/application. If you need to look inside (not likely), you have to know about right-click or the action widget, but for 99.9% of the time, you see only what you need. OS X and Windows also both completely hide "system" folders in Finder/Explorer as well.

Yes, hiding things can be confusing if it's not done right, but the alternative of showing everything always is definitely not the way to go.

link
Dylan16807 5061 days ago
What games reveal skills you have always had, as opposed to unlocking better powers? I would be really annoyed by players-guide-only abilities.
link
jlgreco 5060 days ago
In the Quakes, various movement techniques are only available to those who know they exist. Worked very well I think, lend the games a much longer learning curve.
link
GauntletWizard 5062 days ago
Negative. A lock or shield will convince a user that they're not to touch it, ever... Unless they are too dumb to understand the connotations, in which case they'll simply break it anyway. Hidden files are a good way to go - Out of sight, out of mind for most people, but not impossible to show them when they do need to touch.
link
njharman 5062 days ago
They aren't hidden, completely or otherwise. Dotfiles are locked, '-a' is the key.
link