Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bongodongobob 461 days ago
It happens all the time. DNA double helix is a good example. You really think people are going to mention their drug use in white papers? I think not. Nothing to gain and everything to lose.
1 comments

The record of a scientific discovery that is heavily criticized for plagiarism and falsehoods is probably not a good example, actually.
Well here's one: tons of people do drugs. It's not even a question whether or not drugs have inspired discoveries. They obviously have.
Tons of people eat carrots. That doesn’t imply carrots have inspired discoveries.
That is a textbook false equivalence.
It’s exactly the same argument.
Please explain how they are equivalent and why the psychoactive properties of a psychedelic don't make it categorically different in this situation than a carrot.
Have they? I find it likely, personally, but it doesn’t mean it’s not entirely coincidental either.