Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ChuckMcM 471 days ago
Well it's patented and Tesla doesn't own the patent. But that aside, you trade a different set of problems, specifically what happens if the pack that is put into your car is damaged and as a result of that damage catches fire when it is discharging? That isn't something that happens with gasoline.

I keep hoping flow batteries can overcome their issues as replacing depleted electrolyte with charged electrolyte is much more like 'refueling' in the current sense of the word.

3 comments

A patent on the idea that a battery in something that uses a battery can be replaced has to be the world's most preposterous patent.
Contaminants in fuel can cause damage to cars. I don't know if retailers tend to carry insurance for this but typically they are responsible, although proving it may not be easy. I imagine the risk would be quite rare and fairly well handled with insurance.

What's patented? Seems like a ridiculous patent if it entirely covered all practical manner of swapping batteries to recharge an EV.

Any gasoline can catch fire though, just like probably any battery can catch fire.

At some point we are going to have to stop comparing gas and electric cars.