Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tanseydavid 479 days ago
Would you agree that the Strategic Oil Reserve has exactly the same qualities?
6 comments

Short answer: no.

Long answer: no, oil is needed for the functioning of our society. Helping smooth price volatility is useful and valuable. On the other hand, BTC is not needed for our society to function, and so there is little to no value in managing prices of it. This appears to be an attempt to hedge against the collapse in the trust in the dollar.

> This appears to be an attempt to hedge against the collapse in the trust in the dollar.

Or maybe an attempt to accelerate a reduction of trust in the dollar? Any cryptocurrency in the strategic reserve is being purchase with dollars, which increases the number of dollars in circulation, and will also be directly inflationary (if it’s newly issued dollars) or increases the US debt (if those dollars are obtained by issuing debt, which classical macroeconomic theory suggests is also inflationary).

Maybe it's a good idea to have a currency that isn't being inflated and devalued all the time with every little thing the government does. Kind of gold. Maybe digital gold? I'll call it bitgold. Or what about bitcoin?
That depends on whether there’s a use for oil aside from as a tradable commodity, and additionally on whether there are scenarios in which we might need it for that potential use case in quantities that exceed our ability to easily acquire it.
I dunno, can you fill your tank up with bitcoin when you need to get to work?
Do EMPs destroy the ability to use and exchange oil?
This is beside the point but they actually might. Take out the electric grid, and most other stuff stops working, including gas pumps and refineries.
Oil is notably necessary to keep the united states military operational (in addition to the uses in other comments).
No, I wouldn't exactly call Oil worthless. lol. Thanks for the entertainment tho, with that post.
that’s not “in exchange for nothing”, its in exchange for oil. not terribly complicated.