Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by water-data-dude 478 days ago
Friendly reminder that “most CO detectors use a sensor with a defined, limited lifespan, and will not work indefinitely.”

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxide_detector

2 comments

True. Newer ones will last ~10 years, and will shout an EOL warning when they near the end of their life. I've got hardwired combo smoke and CO detectors (AA battery backup) from Kidde at the house and they have this feature.

The nice part of having them hardwired is that the house is now like an office/other building: if one trips, they all trip, so the whole house is alerted. The newer ones have far fewer false alarms, too (pizza in the oven I am looking at you...).

Battery powered units are literal lifesavers during a blackout, particularly in winter.
My house has hard wired smoke detectors and they all have batteries and all get to chirping on their schedule every 3 years or so.

I'd be willing to bet the NEC says "must be able to perform without mains power" for any hard wired setup.

The battery only CO monitors by Kidde, if I recall correctly, are cheaper than the price of the combined smoke/CO detector minus the price of a Kidde smoke detector. I recently bought a combined unit (ironically because I had a second wireless unit I didn’t recall purchasing that was complaining about low battery near one of the wired units and could not figure out why it was chirping an undocumented signal) and almost put it back on the shelf when I saw the price.

By all means put one in your house but I think it’s a racket to have all four detectors in your house also be carbon monoxide monitors when you can just put a battery unit at the far end of the house from the combined one.

Hardwiring is good, but if retrofitting, you don't need to do it. Some of the 10 year battery powered units can wirelessly link (and thankfully not over something inconsistent like WiFi or Bluetooth).
TIL

Time to visit the hardware store