Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andrewla 476 days ago
My understanding is that it is a copy-on-write clone, not a hard link. [1]

> Q: Are clone files the same thing as symbolic links or hard links?

> A: No. Symbolic links ("symlinks") and hard links are ways to make two entries in the file system that share the same data. This might sound like the same thing as the space-saving clones used by Hyperspace, but there’s one important difference. With symlinks and hard links, a change to one of the files affects all the files.

> The space-saving clones made by Hyperspace are different. Changes to one clone file do not affect other files. Cloned files should look and behave exactly the same as they did before they were converted into clones.

[1] https://hypercritical.co/hyperspace/
1 comments
dylan604 476 days ago
What kind of changes could you make to one clone that would still qualify it as a clone? If there are changes, it's no longer the same file. Even after reading the How It Works[0] link, I'm not groking how it works. Is it making some sort of delta/diff that is applied to the original file? That's not possible for every file format like large media files. I could see that being interesting for text based files, but that gets complicated for complex files.

[0] https://hypercritical.co/hyperspace/#how-it-works

link
aeontech 476 days ago
If I understand correctly, a COW clone references the same contents (just like a hardlink) as long as all the filesystem references are pointing to identical file contents.

Once you open one of the reference handles and modify the contents, the copy-on-write process is invoked by the filesystem, and the underlying data is copied into a new, separate file with your new changes, breaking the link.

Comparing with a hardlink, there is no copy-on-write, so any changes made to the contents when editing the file opened from one reference would also show up if you open the other hardlinks to the same file contents.

link
dylan604 476 days ago
ah, that's where the copy-on-write takes place. sometimes, just reading it written by someone else is the knock upside the head I need.
link
MBCook 476 days ago
That’s correct.
link