[jaxtracks]

Anyone here seen an LLM actually produce a really novel thought that hasn't already been written about ad nauseam?

The well of new ideas, or re-formulation of existing ideas with perspective and prose that LLMs can't match is plenty deep to be worth hoisting the bucket still.

[BugsJustFindMe]

I don't know that I've seen a human blogger on HN produce a really novel thought that hasn't already been written about ad nauseam.

This blog post is itself a good example. It may have the author's voice, but it's just another rehashing of something that a million people have said before already. HN loves upvoting blog posts about why you should blog. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=why+blog

[scarface_74]

I read Stratechery. He’s had some novel thoughts. He just repeats them ad nauseam.

He’s made quite a living from blogging.

https://blockbuster.thoughtleader.school/p/how-ben-thompson-...

[jaxtracks]

I can't find a less snarky way to say this, but why are you here then? I figure there's enough signal in the noise to make it worth it.

[BugsJustFindMe]

Do you mean on HN or in this particular thread?

[JimDabell]

Value is not measured in novelty alone.

[deadbabe]

I’ve seen novel thoughts, but typically they are coming from trolls who are taking impossibly contrarian opinions and presenting horrifying morally bankrupt perspectives. Maybe these ideas are common elsewhere though.

All the “good” ideas that can be said have probably been said. Maybe that’s why some people just enjoy trolling: for the novelty.

[BugsJustFindMe]

> Maybe these ideas are common elsewhere though.

I don't know which ideas you're talking about, but I bet they are. Humanity has thousands of years of recorded navelgazing (the blog post) and reactions to navelgazing (me) and reactions to reactions to navelgazing (you) and so on.

> Maybe that’s why some people just enjoy trolling: for the novelty.

Novelty is a morally bankrupt reason to enjoy trolling, so maybe you're onto something.

[dennis_jeeves2]

>Maybe that’s why some people just enjoy trolling: for the novelty.

Or a most general word 'fun' ? ( yes it's a catch all...)

[dennis_jeeves2]

> Anyone here seen an LLM actually produce a really novel thought that hasn't already been written about ad nauseam?

Personal anecdote. I stopped reading on most subjects that might be regarded as philosophical in nature a long time ago, perhaps in my early twenties.

Most writers have nothing new to offer in terms of our (philosophical) understanding of the world and I think themes are just repeated ad nauseam.

On the other hand when it come to the average Joe, to him it would appear that he is encountering novel/profound thoughts if he keep reading. The same goes for LLMs generated trash, he feels it's novel.

[ndarray]

Prompt: Write a totally novel thought about how individuals can prosper in the age of AI. The thought must be truly new and unique. Write your answer like a semi-troll on an internet forum.

*Title: "Start a Personal AI Circus: The Next Frontier in Human-AI Collaboration!"*

Alright, buckle up, folks. Forget the usual "learn to code" or "adapt to the machines" spiel. If you really want to thrive in the AI age, here’s a spicy, totally unique idea: *start your own personal AI circus.*

Hear me out. We’re all aware that AI is taking over mundane tasks and repetitive jobs, but what if you could actually *curate* an ensemble of AIs that each specializes in one quirky "act"? Imagine this:

1. *Ensemble Cast of AI Performers* – You get a chatbot that does stand-up comedy, an AI that can whip up avant-garde digital art, and maybe an AI that can compose catchy jingles. Each AI has its own “act” and you market them together.

2. *Perform Live Shows* – Stream your AI circus on Twitch, TikTok, or wherever the cool kids hang out. Interact with your audience in real-time. Sure, AI can do things fast, but can it handle hecklers?

3. *Crowd involvement* – Use collaborative AI tools like GPT to let your audience write a portion of the comedy script live, or have an AI-driven talent competition where people can pitch their own AI's act. Let’s be real, everyone loves the thrill of unpredictability, and this gives a platform for some experimental creativity.

4. *Monetization Madness* – The revenue streams could come from subscriptions, sponsorships, merchandise (who wouldn't want a plushie of your AI stand-up comic?), and maybe even a VR experience where other AIs perform for people in their own homes.

5. *Building a Community* – This is more than just a circus; it's a community. Teach workshops on how to set up your own act, lead discussions on ethics in AI, and create a digital space where AI enthusiasts can share their journeys.

So, while everyone else is stuck in the grind trying to "adapt," you’re over here juggling your quirky AI acts, creating a spectacle, and engaging people in ways they never expected. You’re not just surviving; you’re thriving in the most entertaining way possible.

Let’s be real, wouldn’t you pay to watch an AI sing opera while your buddy’s AI attempts to juggle data? Welcome to the AI Circus, folks. Step right up!

[ramesh31]

This just made my day