Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wat10000 479 days ago
But we're talking about stocks, not fish. You can do four things with stocks: exert control over the company, collect dividends, lend it, and sell it. Funds generally aren't buying so they can create wealth by exerting control. Lending and selling are both zero-sum.
1 comments

> Lending and selling are both zero-sum

Why? Lending is just giving people money they value more now than you do, so much so they agree to pay back more later. The utility at the current time of that money is better than the utility later for the lendee, and the opposite is true for the lender (they will happily forego some money available now for more money available later).

If I take a loan out to buy a car which lets me find a better job because I can travel for efficiently, and I get a better job that pays more which allows me to much more money and paying back that loan is itself even easier, is that transaction zero-sum when examined over time?