Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by darkest_ruby 487 days ago
Nobody forced you to buy an iPhone, an android alternative has always existed
5 comments

Android devices run a Google OS and report data to Google. Apple's privacy claims are not actually impressive when inspected, however Android is far, far worse when it comes to privacy violations. It doesn't really matter than the phone itself might be manufactured by a 3rd party. In fact, it could be worse; your data could be excessively leaked to both Samsung and Google, rather than merely Google.
At least with Pixel you can install GrapheneOS.
After giving your money directly to Google.
This is such a bad argument, because for a functional modern smartphone (for non nerds) you need to get into bed with either Apple or Google.

The way out of this is not expecting consumers to install fdroid. It’s putting in place proper regulations to preserve privacy and security for EI societies.

The way out is fixing "you need to get into bed with either Apple or Google" which is the root of the problem.
> It’s putting in place proper regulations to preserve privacy and security

That ship sailed so long ago. Not only because national security demanded warrantless backdoors, but because our companies now control regulation. If Tim Cook or Elon Musk take issue with some pesky demands for open architecture or security audits, they complain to Trump and resolve it via EO. Any protest is already quashed. Phone owners who don't actively resist hold no leverage against their OEM.

Stuff like F-Droid and PostmarketOS is the solution to this particular problem - people just don't want to admit it. It's easier to give up essential liberty, purchase temporary safety, and demand that you deserve security along with it too. Too few people realize that personal freedom is a necessary precondition to personal safety.

Unless you're using Graphene or similar, you're still plugged into a US corporation when using Android.
No matter if you use iPhone or Android - in both cases a US company has full control over it.
Define "full control" for those of us with GrapheneOS installed, pretty please.
So a different American company?