Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cko 488 days ago
When I was Christian, we didn't want to call our system a religion.

Years later when I was exploring Buddhism, no Buddhist I met wanted to refer to Buddhism as a religion.

So the mentality seems to be that everything else is "religion" and what "we" have here is something deeper.

3 comments

As a former Christian, I never experienced anyone avoiding the idea that we were participating in a religious system. In fact, it was a matter of pride, and part of how the church encouraged its members to differentiate themselves from the world.

> Years later when I was exploring Buddhism, no Buddhist I met wanted to refer to Buddhism as a religion.

Having spent hundreds of hours exploring this topic over the last few years, I have to point out that this is because many forms of Buddhism aren't religious at all.

The differences between Christianity and Buddhism in both the underlying philosophical ideas and the manner in which most people practice those ideas could not be more stark.

And as I mentioned in a sibling comment, Zen is a good example of an explicitly non-religious form of Buddhism.

I don't think it's common for Christians not to consider Christianity a religion. At least not where I grew up, in the American bible belt.

Although I can see how calling Christianity a religion implicitly makes it equal to other religions, which Christians might be opposed to, but that doesn't seem like a mainstream point of view.

I remember Bill O'Reilly said in an argument that "Christianity is NOT a religion, it’s a philosophy."

https://youtu.be/T8yyHzA1swA

Hinduism is similarly often described by practitioners as a "way of life" to avoid the religion label.