Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thecopy 484 days ago
They wont admit anything
1 comments

At least we'll get a good example for the Chesterton's Fence wiki page.
Until the Heritage Foundation succeeds in dismantling Wikipedia.
That makes me wonder what the Wikimedia Foundation's disaster recovery plan looks like.

The crucial bit of infrastructure (and the most vulnerable point right now) might be the domain name.

FWIW they have instructions for downloading the whole thing, which mention that it is also downloadable from BitTorrent. So I think it is functionally impossible to delete Wikipedia.

I’d be more worried about propaganda being inserted.

I'm not worried about the data, and even losing the servers would be a hiccup. But whatever site is at www.wikipedia.org is, in the minds of the general public, Wikipedia.

Domain names have been seized in the past.

I imagine most traffic to Wikipedia is through search, so I imagine such a fate is in the hands of search engines. If a community-driven alternative appeared, we'd have to rely on Google indexing this alternative and ranking it higher than the usurped domain.
> I’d be more worried about propaganda being inserted.

FWIW, it would be far from the first time that’s happened (including for sensitive US issues).

It is loaded with propaganda right now.
Is it really a Chesterton's Fence if it's covered in signs saying "do not remove" with simple explanations in large, friendly letters?
Not if you stop understanding or believing the signs.

Very well done doc, though overly concerned, on how keep people in the future away from nuclear waste: Into Eternity https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayLxB9fV2y4