Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jglamine 485 days ago
Makes sense. They want customers to browse using the Netflix app where they can promote their own content. If customers get in the habit of browsing in Apple TV, Apple can promote their own shows and eventually cut Netflix out.

Same reason when you open Netflix it shows new recommendations first, with the option to continue in-progress shows below. Most users will choose the latter, but they don't put it first because it hurts product metrics.

4 comments

>> but they don't put it first because it hurts product metrics.

It's so depressing that instead of making products be the best product they can be for users, we inconvenience users at the expense of 'metrics'. It's a pervasive attitude at tech companies. Apple used to be _mostly_ an exception but even they are doing it now.

Considering how much producing the content costs, it’s baked into all showbiz to try and get as much of the audience hooked on the same thing at the same time by design.

How the UI gets everyone watching shows A, B, and C but not the hundreds of others is a real thing I believe. Part of the “product” if you think about it.

(I’m not a fan of their product and it’s all TPB for me so I’m a cynic)

>it’s baked into all showbiz to try and get as much of the audience hooked on the same thing at the same time by design.

Yes, and that's why a la carte streaming of pretty much any media was a mistake. It's an open secret that none of them are profitable. But everyone was chasing that 2010's ZIRP with no plan whatsoever on how to actually recoup those costs. crashed the market before it really began. So the only answer was to enshittify the service once they had the numbers but not the money.

That's why I really hope games resist this model. It's the exact same honeytrap.

> It's an open secret that none of them are profitable

Netflix is:

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/NFLX/netflix/net-i...

Disney is also profitable:

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/DIS/disney/net-inc...

Apple and Amazon don’t really need to be “profitable”, because the purpose is selling Apple One and Prime bundles.

Warner Bros Discovery could have been profitable too, if ATT had not loaded it up with massive debt by overpaying for it.

Is netflix profitable from income gained, or from expenses "saved"? As Zazlov has shown, you can "make money" if you simply slash a bunch of contracts, layoff employees, and writeoff stuff for tax instead of releasing products. That's pretty much what all companies have done for the past two years

It's not profitable in a way that can work for a decade. It's like cutting off your arm and saying you "lost weight".

> Is netflix profitable from income gained, or from expenses "saved"

Profit = revenue minus expenses, so not sure what this could even mean. It is a function of both variables.

> As Zazlov has shown, you can "make money" if you simply slash a bunch of contracts, layoff employees, and writeoff stuff for tax instead of releasing products.

WBD has yet to show a profit since Zaslav got involved. He has personally lost a ton of wealth due to declining prices of the equity. But, of course, WBD is not a simple case of a media business not being able to sell media, it is a complicated due to the extreme debt it has, which doesn’t say anything about streaming businesses in general.

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/WBD/warner-bros-di...

> It's not profitable in a way that can work for a decade. It's like cutting off your arm and saying you "lost weight".

Back to Netflix, their financial trends show a very successful business. Just check their growth in revenue, profit, and profit margins, for 10+ years.

They might want me in their app but I swear the content Netflix actually encourages me to watch is maybe a hundred titles or so and maybe they rotate in and out a few, but what they want to sell me on always feels the same regardless of my preferences.

They also suffer from "Oh you liked that high quality classic western? how about some garbage westerns?" No man....

I feel like I have to hunt for content on Netflix and I'm boxing with Netflix's suggestions.

> where they can promote their own content

Sounds to me like Apple should allow them to pick a handful of shows to promote as an incentive to integrate into their app.

> Same reason when you open Netflix it shows new recommendations first

This seriously annoyed me to the point where I actually just use plex now.