Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pmontra 493 days ago
A very tangential note about this:

> Much like a door handle should communicate whether to pull or push a door,

For many common doors it's not the handle, it's the frame. Standing on one side of the frame we see that the door is free and we can pull it. On the other side we see that the door hits the frame and we must push it.

1 comments

Yeah, but it's not supposed to. With good design it is immediately obvious whether the door is push or pull - even when the frame doesn't have any clear indications. For example, the door in [0] (apologies for the YT short) has no immediately clear hints if you look at the frame or handle.

Both sides look exactly the same, so how are you supposed to know? Add a "push/pull" sticker you'll miss 90% of the time?

The Vox vodcast(?) in [1] goes a lot further into the problem, starting from a very similar door. The solution is pretty simple, in hindsight: if they designed the door properly, you won't even be able to pull on a push door. Have a pull handle on the pull side, and a push plate on the push side.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/oJnEjV8vQJg

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yY96hTb8WgI