[wruza]

A side effect of this is that a zip.exe that unzips a zip into a book that contains text indistiguishable from the output of a human must reason too.

From what I can see, you’re only massaging semantics. That is uninteresting.

[ninetyninenine]

No. I clearly said it must output novel things that aren’t part of the input.

In your example the book is the training data or aka the input.

[wruza]

Agreed, that was a wrong example.