Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
Ask HN: Who Uses SDKs for Unity/Unreal/Godot?
9 points by logscore 497 days ago
My co-founder and I have been working on SDK generators for application APIs, and we recently discovered that SDKs also exist in the game dev world. Honestly its probably dumb that we didnt know this, but we had never even considered the space so it was quite a blind spot So I have two questions: 1. For game devs: how common is it to use an SDK for Godot/Unity/Unreal/other, and what is that experience like? 2. To the SDK devs: what is the ecosystem/DX like for building game engine SDKs? The closest I've ever gotten to game dev was making a flash platforming game 10 years ago, so any insight is super appreciated.
1 comments
3vidence 495 days ago
From the engines you mentioned (Godot,Unreal,Unity) the game engine itself offers the full SDK suite you need to develop games and it they are tightly integrated with the engine.

I'm most familiar with Unity so I'll speak on that. Unity itself offers the editor (can be configured), debugger, asset manager and visualizer all in the main client. Some people have built external tools on top of Unity for things like no-code game building but the vast majority of developers directly use Unity.

I think Godot is probably the most unique of the ones you listed in that it seems like the one you might can mix and match different tools together but I'm overall much less familiar with it.

link
dualogy 495 days ago
OP asked about "SDK Generators for Application APIs". So my guess is like when you want tight Steam integration in your Godot/Unity/Unreal/etc game, or IAP for mobile game, it's not engine-provided, but some engine-external package/plugin/lib that's sometimes called SDK, sometimes not.

But just my interpretation here =)

link
3vidence 495 days ago
Ahh appreciate the clarification! I was having trouble figuring out what OP was asking.
link
logscore 494 days ago
Yes, that was what I'm referencing.

I understand these engines have their own full SDK for developing with the engine, but I'm curious about the external ecosystem/integrations/libraries. It isn't a space I'm super familiar with, but I'm interested in it, not only from the standpoint of it being an interesting technology I've never played with before, but also because I'm curious if there are similar issues in the game engine SDK space as there are in the application SDK space.

Or maybe even a whole different host of issues and practices. Not sure, that's what I'm looking into.

link