[bluGill]

It isn't possible to have an informed vote for the 500 companies in a S&P index fund and still have a life.

I probably have an informed opinion on the company I work for - but I don't have enough shares to matter. The other 499 I know nothing about.

[vanrohan]

Individually we don't have significant shares, but aggregate it up to BlackRock / Vanguard level, then there is real influence. What is that influence worth? that influence given to the fund manager should be priced correctly. I agree, you probably dont want to have to vote on 500 companies, but to start with it should be an "opt out" decision if you don't care. Alternatively you could allocate your votes to a proxy entity that aggregates like minded investors votes.