Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eamag 499 days ago
Why not combine links in one monthly post similar to https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/links-for-january-2025

I personally prefer this format (https://eamag.me/2025/Links-For-January-2025) and you can post single links on social media instead no?

7 comments

I've settled on posting interesting links to BlueSky and then I put a Bsky sidebar on my site[0]. It's a win-win; I have the small links+comments "on" my site, but the longer stuff that gets posted to RSS/newsletter to my site proper.

[0] https://mattsayar.com

Like the other reply said, a monthly link blog would be too much. I find myself ignoring a lot of those links of the month posts because it covers too many topics and I end up not liking most of it. Whereas one which has small commentary on a single link is great for me, since if i like the commentary enough, I would add the link to my read later.
Some quick ideas:

- Multiple links in the same post make it difficult to organize discussions and thoughts.

- Monthly posts require extra effort to maintain and update, which didn't align with our initial goal of sharing more casually and recording our thoughts in real time.

- Modern static site generators support maintaining archive pages by month, so we no longer need to do it manually.

Hoping those ideas make sense to you.

I think bundling links is better than just throwing one out whenever you find it. If you get one link at a random time, you probably skip it. Unless you are a dopamine addict, in which case I just broke your concentration and fueled a bad habit.

A weekly, or monthly collection is something a reader can take their time for. Or put aside for a moment and come back later to it.

A downside of link bundles is that on an average blog, each installment becomes a page, and one has to click a lot before one gets to the interesting part.

My linkblog therefore sends a collection of links every week via RSS (and others like Bluesky, Mastodon, etc. will follow, if I ever take the time to implement it), but on the web it is just one long list, ready for consumption: https://ewintr.nl/linklog/

Depends on how much commentary you are adding. If more than a sentence it's worth having a separate page so that other people can link to what you said!

My link blog entries are often quite long: https://simonwillison.net/search/?type=blogmark

Just depends how many links. I did this for a couple years at https://f5n.org/stack/ and weekly sometimes felt like too many links already.
I've tended to bunch things up in weekly notes myself: https://taoofmac.com/space/notes