Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by altairprime 503 days ago
What headphones are you using? If they’re fancy enough then your motherboard sound card may or may not be powerful enough / low noise enough / there’s a variety of other things enough / to flap the drivers as precisely as the old board. If they aren’t hella fancy or hella high ohms then this isn’t usually it.

Beyond that. Recon3d is Soundblaster? So they were probably doing a quality level one full step up from what you’d get with a typical motherboard. Something like an Asrock Taichi would typically max out the motherboard tier. Beyond that, you’re into PCIe cards or USB things or HDMI cards that expose a digital device to your PC and do the analog conversion somewhere other than the motherboard.

The conversion from beep-boop binary to analog electrical impulses for your headphone drivers, and the ability to add and remove power to the drivers through your headphone cables, are the two components of quality that you have control over. They’re typically called DAC and amp, and the options in hardware reflect that.

The fastest way to find out whether you’ll be happier with a better sound card is to buy one that has a 15-day return policy; either any modern USB Soundblaster, or a combo dac/amp for headphones like the Schiit Fulla E at ~$100. If that makes it all better and you’re happy, solved!

If it sounds perfectly fine in quality (no hiss, clearly audible music like you prefer) but is ineffably flat or lifeless, you may have had some sort of enhancement processing going on in the old motherboard’s driver that was adding head effects. For that path, make sure you’ve tried out Windows spatial sound > Dolby Atmos for Headphones; it’ll cost a few bucks one-time to activate but it’ll let you test if you were getting virtual surround boosting (or the modern Soundblaster USB devices may have this built in to test with too).

1 comments

Not OP, but here's my audio stuff in case anyone wanted product recommendations:

  (Connected to PC via USB)
  Schiit Modi DAC
  Schiit Vali 2 Headphone Amp (with a tube!)
  PreSonus E4.5 Powered Studio Monitors

  (Connected to phone via USB)
  Aune Yuki DAC
  Meze 99 Classics headphones.
To my ears, both sound pretty good. Especially on the phone, Tidal hires audio seems to sound better. Although I have not performed any double-blind tests or anything!!
(Mjol / Ygg here, but this is quite far out of scope for OP’s question, which is trying to diagnose a change in audio between two motherboards, and I wouldn’t recommend a heavy stack of gear this early on.)