Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pcpuser 500 days ago
> 3) The overreliance on dbus turns the “the unix philosophy” ;) away. Text as a universal communication medium, everything is a file, etc

I prefer an introspectable, typed, and efficient communication protocol over streaming text because of the "Unix philosophy" whatever that may be.

Is the philosophy documented somewhere or is it just in our hearts? Because the Systemd Bus interface has great docs right here: https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/latest/org....
1 comments
dijit 500 days ago
> “ Write programs that handle text streams, because that is a universal interface.”

—Douglas McIlroy

Its difficult to pinpoint a single origin of “everything is a file”, but its referenced in Kernighans memoirs, which is a good read: https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~bwk/memoir.html

link
gf000 500 days ago
Yeah, such a tool will be definitely stable and portable! Until you change the locale and the whole thing breaks apart, with no error message whatsoever..

Also, not even Linux believed in "everything is a file". Everything is either a file or a stream. The two is not the same.

link
dijit 500 days ago
The parent asked a specific question so I gave an answer.

If you disagree that text streams are a good universal medium then thats totally valid, but then perhaps don’t use a unix-like and go for something like VMS, VAX or Windows.

link