[mrsilencedogood]

Difference in grade basically DETERMINES the value. Even small steps down from perfect greatly diminish a card's value. Basically IGN review scale levels of drop-off.

[TylerE]

The issue is people have done careful tests where the send the EXACT SAME card multiples times and get different grades.

ETA: And I don't mean a "reasonable people making subjective judgements" type variation ... I'm talking about like a 6 vs an 8.5 or 9 (out of 10).

[mrsilencedogood]

TBC, I agree with you. I was pointing out how important even small variations in grading can be.