Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fwonkas 5075 days ago
"There's a myth out there that has gained the status of a cliché: that scientists love proving themselves wrong, that the first thing they do after constructing a hypothesis is to try to falsify it."

This sounds horribly wrong to me. Isn't it the "myth" that the scientific community is self-correcting, not individuals?

[edited for grammar]

1 comments

I agree...I thought the common wisdom is that scientists like proving each other wrong. In my experience that is not a myth.
And not even that is necessarily true. I'm a physicist, and I would be wary of trying to prove any commonly accepted theory wrong - even if all my data points that way. Contrary to popular belief, getting data that is too non-mainstream and trying to defend it is often academic suicide in science. While science is one of the most rational fields to be working in, this is still a sad but true fact about the human condition.
And there is Feynman's point that it is less embarrassing to prove yourself wrong, especially if you can do it before you publish.