Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sandspar 523 days ago
Journalism is dying, killed by its own excesses and by the internet. Google is offering it life support. The other option is death.
4 comments

And what are we going to feed into the models without the journalism?
Abrogate the direct primary inputs. Weather sensors. Wildfire cameras. Police scanners. Court proceedings. Changes to ordinances. New LLC filings. Bankrupcies. Birth records. Death records. The whole corpus of society that is automatically logged and used as the primary data for people to then perform research or develop journalism upon.

That is what you siphon up. And in output you can mad lib out an article just like those johnny on the spot AP reporters do anyhow, filling in the skeleton article about a death or an attack or a banquet or award show with the relevant input concerning the event. LLM isn't even used for finding this input but to just adjust the boilerplate, perhaps to tailor news specifically to the reader's own inclinations based on engagement with other articles collected via fingerprinting.

I recommend you find some journalists who's work you find impressive and ask yourself what types of passive inputs could have written pieces like that.
Those represent what 1% of the bulk output of the field if I had to guess? By volume most news is wire service a la terse AP reports that get reposted everywhere. And they have to be terse because it's breaking news and there is no time to opine beyond reporting the inputs mainly as they are in shortform.
Exactly the right question. Journalism has been given a lifeline, a way out of the attention economy.
You might want to look into why "journalism is dying" and whether Google (and Facebook) had anything to do with it.
Theoretical question. What is replacing it? Is it this? Is it something else? Nothing? Curious to peoples thoughts on this.
Potentially social media to a certain degree, at least for raw "news" of what is happening.

Of course that willm be shit, but there we are.

I'd wager 95% of what we call journalism today could simply disappear with no replacement and the world would be better off.
"killed by its own excesses"?
Doubling and tripling and quadrupling down on behaviors that most consumers wish they'd stop doing. You used to work at Google so you must be familiar with how groupthink operates.