Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tony_codes 525 days ago
I strongly disagree with this whole sentiment. The vulnerable need actual protection, not perceived. Invention that is not grounded in reality won't work. Which grand vision starts from falsehood? A possibility not yet proven is not a lie, it's a potential. People united is not a fundamental virtue, people united under virtuous pretenses is of value; people united under a lie is more likely a cult, or a sick society.
2 comments

While transparency and honesty are noble ideals, governments (to take one example) often navigate complex environments involving diplomacy, national security, and political strategy. Do you think it’s possible to run a government entirely devoid of lies? And by government, I am imagining the "for the people, by the people" government that wants good for the people.

Note: I am not pro lies, but challenging myself to think from the other angle.

The official statements on masks, early on during Covid so the limited stock would not be bought out and instead available for medical staff, comes to mind.