Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lolinder 522 days ago
And their peers in the other branches are killing civilians in other ways. Your point?

The only way to hold this against the individuals rationally, especially for those on this forum who would absolutely have chosen Unit 8200 as the least bad option given conscription, is to blame every citizen of the state of Israel and hold them all in distrust for having ever been in any branch of the IDF. I'm personally not okay with that level of sweeping blame and distrust. Are you?

1 comments

> is to blame every citizen of the state of Israel

nobody has said or even implied this

> hold them all in distrust for having ever been in any branch of the IDF

nobody has said or even implied this

> that level of sweeping blame and distrust

There has not been any such thing in this discussion.

We're done here.

Yes, it was done by OP, the comment that was rightly flagged and then later resurrected:

> Just a reminder that Snyk was founded by ex-IDF Unit 8200 soldiers. I would not trust them given what we've seen Israel do to supply chains.

Given that Unit 8200 is staffed by conscripts, how is this anything other than attempting to ensure that any person who ever came of age in Israel has that held against them for the rest of their careers?

Members of Unit 8200 weren't given a choice between that and the private sector—they were given a choice between that and shooting a gun, which for a technically inclined new-adult isn't much of a choice at all. And am I seriously supposed to believe that OP would argue that choosing to be a grunt who shoots a gun at people would be the morally purer choice that would make someone more trustworthy?