Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by klipt 527 days ago
You could also argue that every Spaniard moving from the countryside to the cities takes away houses from Spaniards born in the cities.

Seems like an argument for internal visas like China's household registration system to prevent excessive migration to the cities.

The countryside is mostly emptying out so no need to prevent people moving or buying there.

2 comments

That comparison make sense in a world where the well being of a nation's citizens wasn't the priority of a nation.

However we live in a world where that isn't the case so a nation deciding to restrict immigration or economic activity by foreigners for the benefit of the domestic population is an acceptable position to take -- provided it actually have that desired outcome.

Spoiler: it won't help much.

Liberalizing zoning and taxing land would do more to improve housing affordability.

> Seems like an argument for internal visas like China's household registration system to prevent excessive migration to the cities

With the big difference being the Chinese citizen being denied Beijing hukou is still a Chinese citizen. Madrid should properly first concern itself with Spaniards' wellbeing. (This isn't an argument for or against this policy. Just clarifying why restricting non-EU home purchases is different from hukou.)