Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Wytwwww 533 days ago
Can you not buy more or less as unhealthy products in countries with universal healthcare as in US?

e.g. smoking rate is considerably higher in France or even in Spain

Sugar consumption isn't relatively that high either compared to most European countries:

https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/indicators/indicator-detai...

3 comments

> > smoking rate is considerably higher in France or even in Spain

But they somehow compensate with other good habits considering that lifespan and healthspan is greater than the US.

Then we can get into a whole different conversation about the intensity of one's life in the US v. Europe not just the lenght, but that is a whole different conversation.

That isn't the argument I made. Processed food industries actively block healthcare reforms because they fear being regulated for the now obvious public good.
Perhaps. But I don't think that's the public consensus. So it's hard to accept such arguments without any evidence.

AFAIK in Europe most food safety regulation is coming from the EU directly and not the national governments. Also it's not like all countries in Europe have public tax funded healthcare systems.

Fundamentally some are inherently not that different from the one in the US (i.e. semi-private or even entirely privatized) it's just that they much better regulated and much more efficient.

Even if we exclude private spending the US government already spends more per capita on healthcare than most other countries so why would anything change if e.g. Medicare was extended to a higher proportion of the population?

Any source of that claim? That processed food manufacturers lobbied against universal healthcare for fear of regulation against their products?
America's poor use EBT/food stamps to buy massive amounts of junk food, including billions on soda. Those same people are almost 100% on ACA or state health insurance plans and milking the tax payer on treatment for obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. There is no way, in my mind, it is feasible to fund these lifestyles and provide the treatment for it. Its absolutely insane.
Do they? Food stamps in most states have restrictions on what you can buy with them. My impression is soda is not on the list. Of course this is (mostly?) the states and every state has different rules so you probably need to cite 50 different state rules to verify this and thus an exception state is likely.
This is an ongoing debate, but afaik you can use them for soda [1].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/13/well/eat/food-stamp-snap-...

The soda is not consumed by the food stamp holder. It's used as a medium to convert the balance to cash.