[conception]

Using 1Password requires me to use one of my devices to add a device to my account.

If someone has my password and my device how will a separate app help me in this case?

Honest question as the 1password model seems to be “something you know and something you have”.

[baobabKoodaa]

If someone hacks 1Password, they will get access to all your accounts. Whereas if you moved TOTP off 1Password, that hacker would no longer be able to access your accounts.

[conception]

If someone hacks 1Password, they get an encrypted vault. 1Password has no access to my passwords. There is no recovery mechanism without the encryption keys or a device on the account.