[_yb2s]

From firsthand experience, this simply cannot be true. I can give them totally novel and unique physics problems I just made up- that requires tracking the movement of objects through a series of events, and it answers most correctly. Moreover, they find analogies between disparate concepts and fields of study and make useful suggestions based on them- which is arguably the same process as human creativity.

I think ultimately the disconnect is people theorizing about what it can or cannot do with an incorrect mental model of what it is, and then assuming it cannot do things that it can in fact do. The irony of discussions on LLMs is they more showcase the limits of humans ability to reason about novel situations.