Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rgbrgb 545 days ago
my fam loves boba w zero sugar added... all the places we go to here in san diego let you adjust (e.g. omomo [0]). basically a fresh milky fruit or avocado smoothie with chewy tapioca pearls. it's a fun treat that seemed a lot healthier than an ice cream or something. these findings make me sad :-|

[0]: https://www.omomoteashoppe.com

2 comments

It's funny that you hold up ice cream as a paradigmatically unhealthy food, when most of the studies point in the opposite direction: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/05/ice-cre...

The state of nutrition science is so bad that I wouldn't believe most any study, though.

Ice cream strikes me as a lot healthier than boiled play-doh.
You seem to have a weirdly strong hatred for boba.

It’s okay if something isn’t for you!

Is this based off the tapioca balls? I haven’t considered the health of the balls, but I could see it as being the same as swallowing a bunch of gum.
They are not “gum”. They are mainly starch. They have no nutritional benefit but a do convert a big load of sugars in your blood.
> They have no nutritional benefit but a do convert a big load of sugars in your blood.

That is, like, the definition of nutritional benefit.

It is a very low grade nutrition that produces a lot of unhealthy results. Not really a benefit.
Ben & Jerry’s Cookie Dough has ~25g sugar per 100g.

Boba has ~14g per 100g, depending on the type.

Coca Cola has ~11g sugar per 100g.

In other words, ice cream has 1.8x more sugar content than boba and 2.3x more sugar content of Coca Cola.

If you’re concerned about the tapioca, that’s literally just starch. You know what else contains starch? Potatoes and rice.

> In other words, ice cream has 1.8x more sugar content than boba and 2.3x more sugar content of Coca Cola.

Most Boba Tea cups I’ve seen are far bigger than the typical ice cream.

You can’t use per-100gm doses this way. You have to look at sugar in the product as ordered.

People don’t order and eat their food in neat 100gm increments.

How much people happen to eat in one sitting is nice bonus info, but it doesn't make sense to complain that the data has been normalized into density figures.

Either way, a little 16oz carton of Ben and Jerry's that people smash in one sitting is 1200 calories. So it's still more sugar- and calorie-dense than boba tea.

I don't really see the point in bickering over calorie-dense junk foods though. Both of them are displacing healthier foods in your diet that you could've eaten instead. Neither should account for more than a small fraction of your calorie intake.

Companies vastly differ in serving amounts and some have multiple serve sizes.

What did you expect me to do, bash out a 5x10 multi-company matrix so you can compare perfectly across servings?

> Ben & Jerry’s Cookie Dough has ~25g sugar per 100g. Boba has ~14g per 100g, depending on the type.

Nothing at Boba Guys weighs 100g. That's the difference! 100g really is a typical cup of gelato or ice cream.