Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mgolawala 542 days ago
How is the exchange rate between modern money and "carolus guilders" calculated?

Something like a foreign exchange market cannot help determine this right?

In theory, could the exchange rate for $1 be made equal to 1,200 carolus guilders? (Effectively, making the bonds worthless)

3 comments

There's a pretty continuous line between the carolus guilder and the euro. For example, the modern-day (2002) guilder was fixed at an exchange rate of 2.2 GLD = 1 EUR. Previous coins also had a more-or-less fixed ratio, aided by the value of the gold and/or silver they were made out of.

If you want to treat it like a completely separate coin, you'd have to buy historical carolus guilders in auctions. They seem to be worth about €1500 [0], although the same amount of gold can be bought for only €240.

[0]: https://www.ma-shops.nl/henzen/item.php?id=77815

It would be done stepwise.

When the Dutch florin was introduced there would have been an agreed (or imposed) exchange rate. Looks like that was 1:1.

Later when the Euro was adopted there was an exchange rate for that too.

To get to USD use the floating exchange rate of the open market.

I guess conversely, if you had a bond dominated in say Francs and the currency goes away do you just default?
Currencies rarely "go away". They are usually replaced by new ones, and the government will buy the old currency and pay you in new currency. Imagine the mayhem if a government decided that all money everyone owned would suddenly be completely worthless!
In 2016 India demonetized some bank notes (true, not the whole currency)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetis...