[indoorcomic]

I disagree with the examples in the second idea. The "bad" example is easier to understand and maintain at a glance in my opinion. Looking at the RegisterUser method, I can immediately see the steps it takes to register a user, whereas the "good" example I have to think about it a bit more. Of course, this is a simple example so not much thinking needs to be done, but in a more realistic application I think this would hold much more truth. In projects I've worked on I've seen methods get incredibly bloated due to this. I certainly do agree that "splitting things up for the sake of splitting them up" can be bad practice, I'm just not sure this is the best example to demonstrate that.

[estevaoam]

I agree. The main function of a component should describe what it does, similar to describing the algorithm in natural language. I have been following this pattern with success. It is much easier to understand things at a glance.