Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fragmede 538 days ago
Is that reason because Buffalo is the 81st most populated city in the United States, or 123rd by population density, and Waymo currently only serves approximately 3 cities in North America?

We already let computers control cars because they're better than humans at it when the weather is inclement. It's called ABS.
1 comments
shadowerm 537 days ago
I would guess you haven't spent much time driving in the winter in the Northeast.

There is an inherent danger to driving in snow and ice. It is a PR nightmare waiting to happen because there is no way around accidents if the cars are on the road all the time in rust belt snow.

link
fragmede 536 days ago
I get the feeling that the years I spent in Boston with a car including during the winter and driving to Ithaca somehow aren't enough, but whether or not I have is irrelevant. Still, I'll repeat the advice I was given before you have to drive in snow, go practice driving in the snow (in eg a parking lot) before needing to do so, esp during a storm. Waymo's been spotted driving in Buffalo doing testing, so it seems someone gave them similar advice. https://www.wgrz.com/article/tech/waymo-self-driving-car-pro...

There's always an inherent risk to driving, even in sunny Phoenix, Az. Winter dangers like black ice further multiply that risk but humans still manage to drive in winter. Taking a picture/video of a snowed over road and judging the width and inventing lanes based on the width taking into account snowbanks doesn't take an ML algorithm. Lidar can see black ice while human eyes can not, giving cars equipped with lidar (wether driven by a human or a computer) an advantage over those without it, and Waymo cars currently have lidar.

I'm sure there are new challenges for Waymo to solve before deploying the service in Buffalo, but it's not this unforeseen gotcha parent comment implies.

As far as the possible PR nightmare, you'd never do self driving cars in the first place if you let that fear control you because, you you pointed out, driving on the roads is inherently dangerous with too many unforeseen complications.

link